Don’t pokemon in the wild have friends and families? When a trainer comes along and decides to catch one, what happens? Does the caught pokemon just decide to leave to go with this trainer without letting its friends know, or is there some kind of poke-meeting where they say their tearful goodbyes?

They do indeed have friends and families. However, what happens when you catch one depends on the species.

Many pokémon actually don’t form tightly knit communities, so if they lose one member, they by and large don’t notice. For example, the fields of Kanto are rife with rattata who had left the woods in search of food. The rattata are by and large independent, so if you catch one, the others will simply continue foraging as if nothing had happened. The most they might do is avoid you, but otherwise, they exhibit no change in behavior. If one had young, then the others will simply adopt the abandoned hatchlings or leave them to die. This is, of course, taking into consideration the fact that there is always a risk that the younglings of these pokémon will die anyway, as it only takes a few minutes for predators to raid their nests—which is to say the death of a litter of hatchlings might actually be inevitable if the pokémon has ventured so far from its nest to leave it perfectly exposed to the wild.

Other pokémon never venture away from their nests anyway unless they intentionally wish to leave home. Take clefairy, for example. Clefairy form vast, closely-knit communities, but these communities are well-hidden deep within mountain ranges and cave systems, in places that are nigh inaccessible to humans. Additionally, many pokémon and animals between the clefairy nests and human-accessible parts of these cave and mountain systems eat clefairy or at least will attack them on sight, and clefairy themselves are weaker pokémon not particularly well-suited for battle. Thus, any clefairy you stumble across in the wild is usually one that is dead-set, for whatever reason, to leave home. (Why this is, researchers aren’t quite certain. Some clefairy are curious about the outside world; others wish to get stronger through training.) Thus, it’s morally acceptable to catch these pokémon, as they’re actually far, far from home and very likely have already said their goodbyes.

Conversely, if you do find a clefairy colony or the nests of other pokémon that behave like clefairy, it’s highly recommended that you do not attempt to catch one. The general rule is the larger the group of pokémon, the more likely you’ll want to leave them alone, as taking one will only give the others time to put together an argument as to why you should let their friend go. And by “put together an argument as to why you should let their friend go,” I mean “attack you en masse.” (One clefairy may be ill-suited to battle. Thirty upset clefairy, however, are not.)

And of course, other pokémon are a combination of the two groups mentioned above. They live in flocks or herds that operate in close-knit communities, but they actually don’t mind if you take one of their numbers (unless in the rare case that they do). These pokémon rely on their numbers to defend themselves, and they expect you to understand that the volume of their group is a threat. Many bird pokémon fall into this group, with examples such as pidgey, taillow, and spearow being the hallmarks of this behavior. All of them live in flocks, so if you encounter one, it’s very likely that a few dozen of its friends and family are very close by. However, if you catch one, then very likely, that few dozen of its friends or family won’t mind. (Why this is comes down to the fact that most pokémon understand there are benefits to forging relationships with humans.) On the other hand, if you attempt to catch a spearow, and the other spearow feel strongly about not parting with their friend, they will let you know … by also attacking you en masse.

In short, this is why it’s a good idea for trainers to exercise extreme levels of caution when dealing with wild pokémon. Many will allow you to catch them, yes, but there are several that will not. You’ll be able to figure out which is which simply by observing them and watching out for others like them. If it looks like it or its friends feel threatened by your presence, leave them alone. Finally, always remember that pokémon are absolutely capable of defending themselves, especially in groups.

Are there any pokemon that are considered “taboo” to eat or are they all pretty much game? (as long as they are farmed or hunted properly of course)

Well, if you hunt it, it’s by definition game.

Bill. —LH

Edit: Right, right. Terribly sorry.

Generally speaking, there are quite a few pokémon humans should not eat, either due to cultural issues or simply because not all pokémon can be eaten.

First and foremost, there are the legendaries, as these are culturally significant—although the sheer difficulty in obtaining one would make this moot anyway. Ghost-types and dragon-types are likewise considered to be untouchable for the exact same reason.

Second and equally obvious are pokémon that are not edible to begin with. This category includes all rock-types and most steel-types due to body composition (excadrill is the only exception when it comes to steel-types, as the others either possess armor or are taboo for other reasons), as well as many poison-types due to the difficulty in removing their venom. As noted in earlier entries, there are other poison-types that are completely fine to eat so long as they’re prepared with the utmost care. These are typically the more animal-like poison-types. The less animal-like a poison-type is, the more likely it is to be lethally poisonous, with pokémon such as grimer, koffing, and trubbish (as well as their evolved forms) being particularly deadly.

Additionally, there are members of other types that are also not edible, including slugma, the baltoy line, the porygon line, the voltorb line, cryogonal, the bergmite line, and anything whose special ability is either Flame Body or Magma Armor. Grass-types tend to be either-or on the subject; of the non-poisonous species, anything that is not made of or covered in wood may be eaten.

Ditto is likewise not edible for reasons similar to the problem facing poison-types. As ditto produce more ditto by budding, breaking off a piece of one (say, by biting it) is not a guarantee that what you consume will actually be dead, and it’s not easy to kill a ditto, either. Which is to say, consuming a ditto, even cooked, may result in a very unpleasant death for the person daring enough to try it.

On a technical level, psychic-types are also considered to be inedible, although this is largely because all psychic-types possess a telepathic defense mechanism. In other words, attempting to kill a perfectly healthy psychic-type, even using humane slaughtering techniques, may result in permanent brain damage. It’s simply not worth it.

Among the pokémon that are technically edible, only a percentage is universally or culturally acceptable to eat. We do not, for example, kill and eat pokémon that greatly resemble humans, including the machop line, the tyrogue line, the timburr line, the makuhita line, sawk, and throh (as well as those that are also psychics, such as jynx and gardevoir). Likewise, most cultures frown on the consumption of “pet” pokémon, such as the clefairy and jigglypuff lines, as well as starters, monkey- or ape-like pokémon, and all feline, equine (yes, including blitzle and zebstrika), and canine pokémon. Pokémon known for their healing attributes, such as audino and chansey, are also taboo, although chansey’s eggs are fair game (but only if the chansey freely gives you one). Speaking of eggs, the togepi line is also frowned upon, despite the fact that many cultures have plenty of jokes concerning the slaughtering of togepi for breakfast.

Finally, if it’s rare, then there are actually government regulations in place protecting those species from being hunted. Farfetch’d is a notable example of this, as there was a period of time in which they had been overhunted (due to not only the taste of their meat but also the convenience of having your main course carry its own garnish around as a weapon) to the point of near-extinction in Kanto and Johto. Thanks to strict regulations that had been implemented fairly recently, the farfetch’d population is only now regaining its numbers. Other pokémon that enjoy government protection include wailmer and wailord (in Unova, Alola, and Kalos), lapras, carvanha and sharpedo, and absol (especially in the Hoenn region).

I suppose the shorter answer would be “if you would eat the animal, plant, or thing they resemble, then you may eat them.” But short answers are hardly fascinating, in my view.

I do sometimes wonder if our understanding of types is also based in part on their having both an attack and pokemon component. Is that why Sound isn’t a type, for example? It has “attacks” in that some pokemon are immune to sound-based moves as a category, but there are no known pokemon that exhibit different weaknesses and resistances that would classify the pokemon themselves as Sound. Am I close?

That’s certainly part of it, @emeraldmew. Putting it another way, all attacks are also sorted based on elemental resonance, so what they are tends to be clearer cut than a pokémon’s attributes. Or, rather, they were after we redid the classification system in the late 90s. Before then, pokémonologists considered certain moves to be types they most certainly weren’t. Gust, for example, had been a normal-type move, and Bite was normal until we created the dark-type classification. In recent years, the only moves that had been subject to reclassification were non-damaging fairy techniques such as Sweet Kiss, and that was partly due to the fact that it’s harder to determine the elemental resonance of something that doesn’t do damage to a pokémon and partly because we had only recently created the fairy-type designation.

Nonetheless, the point is, techniques all have elemental resonances, and the way these elements interact with a pokémon’s physical attributes (that is to say, their body, not simply what one might consider “physical defensive abilities” or “defense”) is how we categorize types. While sound-based moves such as Hyper Voice and Uproar have a consistent pattern of use, the problem lies in the fact that not all sound-based moves resonate with the same element. For example, Hyper Voice is considered to be a normal-type move because it behaves as a normal-type technique would. Bug Buzz, meanwhile, integrates an insectoid element into its use, which is why it’s super effective against types Hyper Voice is only neutral to. This is true with every sound-based technique, which leads researchers to believe that there is no move that has a “sound resonance.”

But it’s really more than that as well. Just as we’ve observed (so far) that there isn’t a sound element, we’re able to observe the way other, established elements interact with pokémon. For example, take swirlix, a pokémon who is classified as fairy. The way type research works is scientists expose each pokémon to the eighteen known elements and record their reactions. Likewise, we record data concerning the way the subject uses each element as well. Combining both sets of data, we’re able to cross-reference and see not only what the pokémon failed to or was able to resist but also which elements the pokémon wielded best. Any discrepancies point towards the possibility of a new type.

Swirlix was among the first pokémon to be officially registered as fairy, and as such, it was also one of the reasons why scientists went back to reclassify pokémon that had already been entered in to the National Dex. Originally, it was proposed that swirlix was a normal-type and that many of its natural techniques—namely Fairy Wind, Play Rough, and Draining Kiss—were either normal or flying. However, by observing not only the way the dragon type interacted with swirlix and the way swirlix was more adept at using those three aforementioned moves than the actual normal techniques it knows, it was determined that swirlix and its basic movepool may not be a normal-type at all.

In short, you’re more than close: moves are part of the pokémon classification system. They’re part of a very complex taxonomy that calls upon a number of different variables centered around the way pokémon interact with them and vice-versa. For that reason, though, it can be difficult to recognize when a type exists, but as sound-based moves do not produce consistent results among sets of pokémon, it’s very unlikely that a sound-type exists.

Or in even shorter terms … yes.

Hello Bill! Since you’ve done a dex entry for the Kanto Gym Leaders, do you think you can do one for the Johto Gym Leaders too? I’m mostly curious about your thoughts on my favorite bird dweeb Falkner, hehe! :)

Hmm. Well, seeing as I’ve just reached 250 followers and I haven’t yet died after posting my analysis of the Kanto gym leaders…

That is a terrible reason to assume this is okay, but on the other hand, I’m impressed Lt. Surge only let you off with a warning. Therefore, I’m going to let you continue, just because I’d like to see whether or not Clair would do the same. —LH

And seeing as my editor is my dearest friend who is always concerned about my well being…

Falkner
The Elegant Master of Flying Pokémon
Type: Flying
Positon: First Badge—Zephyr
Entry: The newest gym leader within the Johto circuit, Falkner had recently inherited both his gym and his bird pokémon from his father. Whether or not he’s as graceful as his equally inherited gym leader title implies has yet to be determined, but from what the author has seen on the occasions when all of the previous generation of kimono girls gather with their children … the answer is no. Apologies to his fangirls.

Bugsy
The Walking Bug Pokémon Encyclopedia
Type: Bug
Positon: Second Badge—Hive
Entry: A young expert in bug-type pokémon, Bugsy knows everything there is to know about his specialty, including the inner workings of moves that he had discovered himself. He has been known to go on for some time about the mysteries and beauty of bug-types, regardless of his listener’s level of interest. One could say that Bugsy is a bug-type maniac, preferring the company of his own bugs to people while valuing the importance of even the tiniest weedle. In short, Bugsy is the author’s favorite, as he is apparently a trainer after his own heart.

Whitney
The Incredibly Pretty Girl
Type: Normal
Positon: Third Badge—Plain
Entry: A minor celebrity in her hometown of Goldenrod City, this gym leader is known for her cuteness, her fashionable tastes, her skill on the battlefield, and her generally charismatic personality. These are absolutely things she is known for, and the author is not at all downplaying any negative aspects of her personality (such as talkativeness, nosiness, or overabundance of energy … which are traits she certainly doesn’t have) because he realizes she knows where he lives, is good friends with his mother, and will never let him hear the end of it if he says anything to the contrary.

Morty
The Mystic Seer of the Future
Type: Ghost
Positon: Fourth Badge—Fog
Entry: A talented psychic, this gym leader has trained for the majority of his life to hone his abilities, all with the hopes of one day meeting Ho-oh. As a result, Morty is a formidable battler with a plethora of talents, including the abilities to see spirits and the future. Unfortunately, given his self-appointed title, writing is apparently not among the aforementioned talents.

Chuck
His Roaring Fists Do the Talking
Type: Fighting
Positon: Fifth Badge—Storm
Entry: A manly individual who trains for nearly twenty-four hours a day beneath the roaring waterfalls of his gym. Nothing can convince this man to do anything, not even challengers, the league rules (concerning the proper formatting of gym titles in the Johto region) … or his unfortunately beleaguered wife.

Jasmine
The Steel-Clad Iron Defense Girl
Type: Steel
Positon: Sixth Badge—Mineral
Entry: A shy, sweet, and soft-spoken girl with a compassionate heart, Jasmine is both a friendly individual who is eager to make friends … and a steelix-wielding warrior princess who is fully capable of breaking every bone of the author’s body without pokémon. Needless to say, the author thinks Jasmine is a wonderful girl.

Pryce
The Teacher of Winter’s Harshness
Type: Ice
Positon: Seventh Badge—Glacier
Entry: A battle-hardened veteran trainer and a master of the ice type. The author is certain that Pryce is a wise individual who has plenty to teach the younger generations, but most of his conversations with this particular gym leader were more like one-sided rants about how modern technology is a plague to human existence and how the author in particular has contributed to the laziness and/or downfall of his own generation.

Clair
The Blessed User of Dragon Pokémon
Type: Dragon
Positon: Eighth Badge—Rising
Entry: A beautiful, talented, vastly intelligent, magnificently wise, and uniquely powerful mistress of dragon pokémon with whom the author has no quarrel. (Please don’t hurt me.)

How well do pokemon (particularly wild) understand human language? They seem to understand commands – such as attacks – as soon as they’re caught. Would a pokemon from a french speaking region understand a command from an english or spanish speaking trainer?

Although there are a number of people in Johto who claim to be “pokémon speakers,” or those who can speak with pokémon, and although there are a few pokédex entries that imply otherwise, in truth, most pokémon can understand human speech just fine. It’s just that most pokémon—especially wild ones—respond better if a human attempts to speak with them in their “native language.” However, this is just because it’s easier to hold their attention this way; if you attempt to hold any sort of conversation with a pokémon, they should have no problem following what you’re saying.

Of course, things get complicated with languages, but for the most part, this is one of the reasons why we converted to an international language with the establishment of pokémon leagues. The other reason, of course, is because it’s easier for trainers to enter foreign leagues if they didn’t have to deal with a language barrier. This is why it’s easy for a ten-year-old from Japan to enter the Unova League.

For pokémon, meanwhile, it’s less of a chore to translate what humans are saying because we, for the most part, are speaking only one language, and that language was itself constructed from a pokémon tongue. This language, for those who are less well-versed in etymology (I know we don’t normally teach this in school for whatever reason) is Common, which is a language based entirely on the unown. For this reason, pokémon are capable of latching onto what we say because in a way, we are speaking one of their languages—just not their native language. (This is why we can’t exactly understand them unless we make a concerted effort to do so. Johtonian pokémon speakers rely on this fact in order to perform, but all they’re really doing is making more of an effort than most people to listen.)

Of course, it’s entirely possible for a human to speak one of the old languages such as French or Japanese, but this tends to cause more confusion than it’s worth, especially given how interconnected we are as a species at this point.

Do certain species of pokemon mate for life like some animals do? Or is it up to each individual’s own preferences?

Well, some part of it is up to the individual’s preference. While divorce is not a concept that exists among pokémon, capriciousness is.

On a serious note, absolutely, there are plenty of pokémon that mate for life. Many of the human-shaped ones do. The ralts line, for example, is well-known for it, although there are plenty of others, including the gothorita line, the mr. mime line, the machop line, the abra line (despite being fox-like as well), and so forth. Some dog-like pokémon such as the riolu line also do. Bird-like pokémon are also known for it, with some—such as swanna and members of the murkrow line—being symbols of monogomy for this exact reason. And of course, there are a few non-avian pokémon that are also monogamous, such as members of the deerling line, durant, finneon and lumineon, many rodent pokémon, and—of course—luvdisc.

Honestly, just about the only kinds of pokémon that are consistently not monogamous are the more “inanimate-like” pokémon, such as rock-like pokémon, genderless pokémon that can still mate, and a number of plant-like pokémon.

How safe is battling for pokemon? Can pokemon attacks actually do serious damage to pokemon or is “fainting” the worst that can happen?

So long as you’re engaging in league-sanctioned battles or battles against wild pokémon, they’re perfectly safe. There are strict rules within every pokémon league that prevent trainers from killing or seriously injuring opponent pokémon. It’s like boxing or wrestling: in legitimate matches, you absolutely cannot do permanent damage to your opponent, as any more than that constitutes manslaughter or even murder. The same concept applies to league-sanctioned battles. While you can’t be blamed for acts of God (although in some cases, the architect of the stadium might be), if you consciously attempt to disobey the referee and continue the match past the point where your pokémon or your opponent’s has fainted, you could be arrested after the battle if anything serious happens. However, if you engage in a league-sanctioned battle, you will either do so under the watch of an official referee (who will always call the match before any serious damage occurs), or you will outline the rules to a fellow trainer beforehand (so the both of you enter a verbal agreement to fight while following league regulations).

As for wild pokémon battles, wild pokémon typically have no interest in killing other pokémon except in extreme cases of self-defense. Wild pokémon are intelligent enough to recognize when an enemy has been incapacitated, and thus, they will leave you alone if you make it apparent that you won’t harm them after the match is over. (Note: For the most part. Some of the more aggressive pokémon or pokémon who believe you’re trying to kill them will make an attempt on your life and the lives of your pokémon, so it’s a good idea to exercise good judgment while in the wild. Do not, for example, attack a singular spearow, as spearow are just ornery and violent enough to call the rest of their nearby flock to attack you back.)

That having been said, there are also underground pokémon matches, or battles between trainers in settings that aren’t exactly by-the-book. You’ll know when you’ve found such a place when trainers never outline rules to one another or when large crowds gather to take bets on the matches. These matches are usually done to-the-death, and thus, they’re far less safe for either the pokémon or the trainers involved. Needless to say, they’re highly illegal and frowned upon by most societies, but due to their underground, secretive nature, it’s difficult to prevent them from occurring. The best advice I can give you regarding these is never battle in an arena unless you know for certain that it’s league-approved, and certainly don’t battle against a trainer who agrees to league rules beforehand.

So typings are interesting. Before the Fairy type was discovered, some pokemon (granbull, clefable..) were classed as Normal types, meaning they should be weak to Fighting and not weak to Poison and Steel, etc. Now they’re Fairy type and all this has just changed dramatically… How do types work?

Allow me to use a metaphor to explain.

Let’s say it’s the middle of summer, and you put a group of human beings in a room with no air conditioning. All of these humans are physically the same species, but some tolerate the ensuing heat more than others. On one extreme of the spectrum, you have the people who are perfectly fine sitting in a hot room. On the other, you have the people who become lethargic and moody—even a little sick. Everyone else is somewhere in between.

Types are like that. You may have a number of pokémon that are all the same type, but not all of them will express the type’s signature weaknesses and resistances the same way. For example, some rock-types take fire-type attacks without flinching, while others feel visibly uncomfortable by proximity to heat. Conversely, magnemite and a number of other steel-types absolutely hate heat, but lucario and more mammalian species are more capable of tolerating it (so long as they aren’t exposed to direct fire). This is why it’s often difficult to pinpoint a pokémon’s type.

Also, think of it like any other element of taxonomy. Yes, to researchers, pokémon types are merely another form of taxonomy, or classification of living organisms. With the broader classification of organisms, system used by modern scientists splits all organisms into seven kingdoms: Bacteria, Protozoa, Chromista (for algae), Plantae, Fungi, Animalia, and Pokémonica. Sixty years ago, however, there were only four kingdoms, as scientists grouped algae and fungi with plants and pokémon with animals. As our understanding of the world grew, we realized that this system was insufficient to describe the organisms we were studying, and so, the system changed to fit our needs. Types, being another form of taxonomy, are just as fluid as the grand system of taxonomic ranks.

That is to say, although we researchers do our best to classify pokémon accurately, sometimes, our way of describing them needs to change due to newly acquired information. The fairy type is actually an excellent example. The pokémon that have been reclassified into that particular type have a wide variety of offensive and defensive capabilities, as well as a variety of secondary types, all of which made it difficult for researchers to notice that they shared any characteristics between them.

For example, clefable and wigglytuff are both hardy pokémon, but because of that, both are able to withstand venomous attacks far better than a number of other fairy-types on record. As such, scientists didn’t realize either of them had a weakness at all until their battling abilities were compared to other normal-types. (In actuality, it was only recently pointed out that both types weren’t simply tolerating Dragon Claw and other dragon-type attacks due to their hardiness; they were quite simply immune to dragon moves. After that, a full-scale study was done on them to determine why.)

Conversely, gardevoir is a far more fragile pokémon than clefable and wigglytuff, and as such, it was originally thought that its weakness to both poison and steel can be easily explained by its lack of defensive capabilities. It certainly didn’t help that its secondary type could easily dispatch both poison and fighting—the latter of which gardevoir boasts a double resistance to—making understanding the abnormalities of the species’ weaknesses and strengths particularly difficult to understand. It was only after we had compared gardevoir’s ability to withstand bug- and dark-types to gallade’s that anyone had realized that perhaps there was something else going on.

The point is that the type classification system is a classification system first and foremost. Each pokémon within every type actually has differing tolerance thresholds when it comes to withstanding other elements. Even clefable and granbull—both mammalian pokémon who were reclassified from pure normal-types to pure fairy-types—don’t handle poison and steel moves in the exact same way. Ultimately, however, whenever the scientific community obtains new information that sheds brand-new light on a group of pokémon, we change the classification system as necessary.

Can pokemon have different markings than the ones in “official artwork” or in the pokedex? For example are all Charmanders plain orange and cream, or could they have, say, a few brown spots or something?

If by “official artwork,” you mean photographs in the pokédex, absolutely. The pokédex images are merely photographs of the specimen a trainer or researcher has on hand. Actual wild pokémon may possess markings that might vary greatly due to a number of factors, including environment, certain genetic factors, physical condition, and so forth.

More specifically:

  • Pokémon may change colors in response to their environment. This not only refers to adaptive evolution but also individual response to environmental influences, including the chemistry of the available food sources. For example, even visiting pokémon to Pinkan Island in the Orange Islands archipelago have been known to turn pink due to the fact that pinkan berries—a rare, pink berry that happens to be high in lycopene—are the most reliable food source for pokémon on the island. (On that note, it’s highly recommended that trainers feed their pokémon commercially produced kibble while on the island unless they want a pokémon the color of a jigglypuff.)
  • But yes, evolution is also a possibility. Take the Alolan and Kantonian vulpix, for example. Vulpix in Kanto have adapted to warmer climates, and hence, they possess a fire-red coat of coarse, short hair. Alolan vulpix, meanwhile, thrive primarily in colder, snowier climates. Thus, they sport snow-white coats that allow them to blend in with their surroundings, and their fur is thick and soft enough to trap the heat they need to survive cold, wintry nights.
  • While pokémon inherit the species of their mother (unless that mother is a ditto), it’s not at all unusual for some to inherit traits from either parent. It’s not normally so drastic as to produce pokémon that are entirely a different shape or color than the ones you might see in your pokédex, but as an example, a meowth whose father was a pikachu may have more golden fur than normal, whereas a meowth whose father was an eevee may have thicker fur around the neck and a bushier tail. In short, the meowth will still be immediately recognizable as a meowth, but certain traits may be slightly different from the official photograph thanks to its father.
  • Pokémon fur, skin, and so forth are notably more vibrant the healthier the pokémon in question is, and likewise, fur will usually be thicker and shinier. By contrast, duller, grayer, or thinner fur or skin indicates a general illness. Likewise, pokémon with unusual spots, lumps, or moles may be suffering from cancer, cysts, or other unfortunate conditions, and pokémon can certainly be born with deformed limbs. Alternatively, some injuries sustained on the battlefield or elsewhere may lead to permanent damage, such as scars, missing eyes, torn limbs, and so on. Old age can also bring about arthritis, which in some pokémon pronounces itself via enflamed joints. If your pokémon suddenly changes in physical appearance or if you have a pokémon with any physical condition that seems a little unnatural, it’s best to take them to a pokémon center for an examination.
  • Of course, these are just a few of the most likely possibilities for an explanation as to how you might acquire a pokémon with unusual spots. There are certainly others as well, including the possibility that you’ve just encountered a specimen in a particularly dire need of a bath.

bird-nerd-the-third:

@bills-pokedex

Hey Bill, how do you feel about people who hate common Pokemon such as Pidgey and Zubat? I’m mostly concerned about the Pidgey haters here, because it makes me so angry when anyone insults Flying-type Pokemon. I believe Pidgey are wonderful little birds that evolve into something amazing. It’s not their fault that they’re very common around Kanto and Johto, and I think that just because a Pokemon is common doesn’t mean that it’s any less interesting. What do you think? I’d like to hear an expert’s take on common Pokemon. Especially Pidgey.

Ah, hello, Falkner! I hope all is well at your gym!

To answer your question, short of phobias and trauma-induced fear, I’ve never understood how anyone could hate a pokémon, to be honest. Although, yes, some pokémon are a bit more intimidating than others, all of them are wondrous, fascinating creatures, and it’s important to acknowledge both this and the fact that we share our world with them.

It’s also important to put things in perspective. While humans are the dominant species of this planet, it’s true that pokémon are far more powerful and far older (generally speaking) than we are. Even magikarp possess the capability of overpowering a grown man, so it’s only by our own cleverness and our usefulness to pokémon that we may continue to exist in their world, rather than the other way around. This isn’t to say that we actually live in a dystopia centered around a delicate balance between humans and pokémon. It’s more to say that we humans have a duty to respect and care for all nature, including the pokémon that inhabit it. The world and all the pokémon in it can survive without us; we can’t survive without them.

Of course, this is just a word on pokémon in general, but pidgey and other common birds are most certainly included in this statement. Pidgey, pidove, hoothoot, and all the others are just as important to this world as ho-oh, charizard, and all the other rare pokémon one can think of.