Are totodiles supposed to learn flamethrower??? My Bitey just straight up flamethrowered his opponent in battle. I’m concerned and a little Afraid

Not normally, no, so I admit this is a bit odd.

On the other hand, there have been reports—albeit very, very rare ones—of pokémon using moves they wouldn’t normally be able to use. For example, one of Lance’s dragonite apparently knows how to use Whirlwind, despite the fact that the species’ wings are far too small for such a move (hence why almost all other dragonite can’t learn that move). Likewise, one of Wikstrom’s scizor can use Shadow Claw, despite the fact that the scyther family can’t actually channel ghost-type energies to begin with.

Needless to say, such instances are of great fascination to researchers because we’re not quite sure how pokémon can learn these moves. Certainly, most of them can improvise Tackle or Peck (which happens so frequently that it’s actually considered a bit of a different story), but something like Shadow Claw or, in your case, Flamethrower is a lot more complex. One popular theory is that in some cases, such as in Wikstrom’s, a trainer may be so skilled that they can overcome certain physical limitations in order to unlock potential hidden deep, deep within every pokémon.

The other, which addresses cases of accidental move tutoring, is that these moves are actually improvised from completely different techniques or elements and merely channeled into approximations of other moves. For example, the scizor family is capable of channeling dark-type energy, which often behaves in the same manner as the ghost-type, so what we see as Shadow Claw might actually be more accurately called a Dark Claw. (On the other hand, having seen Wikstrom’s battles, it’s more likely that he’s simply a very, very skilled move tutor in line with the first theory…) In your case, meanwhile, either you have an exceptionally talented totodile, or your totodile attempted to harness the dragon-type energies it does have access to in order to execute an improperly formed Dragon Pulse. Perhaps even Hidden Power.

Best of luck on harnessing this rather fascinating gift!

So I went to get my first Pokémon… and was told the order of balls was Cyndiquil, totodile, chikorita. Well I chose left, which was supposed to be cyndiquil but when I got home it was a totodile that came from the ball. Is it common for these mistakes to happen?

If you start anywhere other than New Bark Town? Not at all, as most professors label their poké balls clearly, or the poké balls are up-to-date and thus come with the usual identifying panel that pops up whenever you press the front button.

In New Bark Town, however, which is where you might have been if that was your array of starters, yes, but that’s largely because a certain professor is a bit, shall we say, absentminded.

Terribly sorry for the mix-up, anonymous. There is a chance that if you take the ball back as soon as you can (before the totodile properly bonds with you), you might be able to trade it for a cyndaquil. The professor in question has had this happen frequently enough that, yes, he does keep a few extra on hand; it’s just that your totodile needs to have not bonded with you for the exchange to be made.

The Totodile Line

Totodile
The Big Jaw Pokémon
Type: Water
Official Registration #: 158
Entry: One of three pokémon traditionally offered to new trainers at the beginning of their journeys in Johto. A small but hardy alligator pokémon, totodile possess jaws strong enough to crush the front bumper of a car. Although it is frequently advised by experts to take caution when handling this pokémon, even those experts sometimes have difficulty avoiding injury from a totodile bite. So, logically, certain Johtonian researchers have reached the admirably sage conclusion that this is the perfect pokémon to offer to young and heavily inexperienced trainers.

Croconaw
The Big Jaw Pokémon
Type: Water
Official Registration #: 159
Entry: The evolved form of totodile, by battle experience. Croconaw’s primary form of attack is to use its huge, powerful jaws to bite down onto its opponent. Once latched on, it never lets go until it loses its teeth, which grow back harmlessly within a day. So to the young and inexperienced trainers mentioned in the previous entry, rest assured that your croconaw’s teeth will grow back shortly after they lose them, which should be one less thing to worry about as you seek medical attention for the reason why your pokémon lost its teeth in the first place.

Feraligatr
The Big Jaw Pokémon
Type: Water
Official Registration #: 160
Entry: The evolved form of croconaw, by battle experience. Despite its bulky appearance, feraligatr is a swift pokémon, capable of rushing at an opponent with blinding speed. Once it corners an opponent, it tears into its victim with its massive jaws, savagely tearing them apart within seconds.

Which, in combination with the damage the other two evolution lines can do to a human being, should explain why the author is immensely curious as to how a certain professor gained permission from the Johto League to hand out starters.